{"id":2185,"date":"2012-09-28T20:26:43","date_gmt":"2012-09-28T20:26:43","guid":{"rendered":"http:\/\/hopoi.org\/?p=2185"},"modified":"2012-09-28T20:26:43","modified_gmt":"2012-09-28T20:26:43","slug":"iran-tribunal-impossible-to-continue-support","status":"publish","type":"post","link":"https:\/\/hopoi.org\/?p=2185","title":{"rendered":"Iran Tribunal: \u2018Impossible to continue support\u2019"},"content":{"rendered":"<p>\t\t\t\t<strong>Norman Paech, a prominent member of the German left Party Die Linke, has joined others in withdrawing his support for the Iran Tribunal after approaches from supporters of Hands Off the People of Iran, reports Tina Becker<\/strong><\/p>\n<p><em>This is an edited version of an article recently published on the website of the German magazine Hintergrund.<a title=\"\" href=\"#_edn1\"><strong>[i]<\/strong><\/a><\/em><\/p>\n<p>The Iran Tribunal continues to divide the left. Yassamine Mather\u2019s articles in the <em>Weekly Worker <\/em>have been hotly debated in Iran<ins cite=\"mailto:MF\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T09:07\">, <\/ins>across Europe and the United States. Since she started to expose the links of the organisers to the National Endowment for Democracy (NED), a number of organisations and individuals have withdrawn their support. Other groups and parties have split over the issue.<\/p>\n<p>It is therefore timely to take a closer look at the tribunal, its gestation, its corruption \u2013 and the fallout from Hopi\u2019s <ins cite=\"mailto:MF\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T09:24\">scathing <\/ins>criticism.<\/p>\n<p><strong>Supportable aims<\/strong><\/p>\n<p>During the 1980s, tens of thousands of political activists in Iran were arrested, tortured and sentenced to death. Many leftists <ins cite=\"mailto:MF\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T09:09\">fled <\/ins>abroad and around 20,000 dissidents were murdered. The worst massacre <ins cite=\"mailto:MF\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T09:24\">was <\/ins>in the summer of 1988, when between 5,000 and 7,000 political prisoners were systematically executed in a matter of weeks, their bodies dumped in anonymous mass graves.<\/p>\n<p><a href=\"http:\/\/hopoi.org\/wp-content\/uploads\/execution3.jpg\"><img loading=\"lazy\" decoding=\"async\" class=\"alignleft size-full wp-image-2188\" style=\"margin-left: 5px; margin-right: 5px; border: 2px solid black;\" title=\"execution3\" src=\"http:\/\/hopoi.org\/wp-content\/uploads\/execution3.jpg\" alt=\"\" width=\"348\" height=\"250\" \/><\/a>Since then, the relatives and former comrades of those killed have fought for justice. But how to do that in today\u2019s <ins cite=\"mailto:MF\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T09:25\">world<\/ins>? That\u2019s the question that has <ins cite=\"mailto:MF\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T09:25\">sparked <\/ins>heated debates amongst the Iranian left. They are united in the view that a first, important step should be the publication of the details of the massacre. After all, the government in Teheran has never <ins cite=\"mailto:MF\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T09:27\">admitted <\/ins>the<ins cite=\"mailto:MF\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T09:27\">se<\/ins> crimes and continues <ins cite=\"mailto:MF\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T09:28\">its cover-up<\/ins>. Many of those responsible remain in power. <ins cite=\"mailto:MF\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T09:29\"><\/ins><\/p>\n<p><ins cite=\"mailto:MF\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T09:29\">\u201c<\/ins>For many years, we have been fighting for an independent commission <ins cite=\"mailto:MF\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T09:29\">to <\/ins>examine the horrific murders and name the guilty parties. Our model is the Russell Tribunal, which was established by Bertrand Russell and Jean-Paul Sartre in 1967 and which exposed very effectively the crimes <ins cite=\"mailto:MF\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T09:29\">committed by the <\/ins>US military in Vietnam<ins cite=\"mailto:MF\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T09:30\">\u201d, <\/ins>says Yassamine Mather, who has been living in exile in London for almost 30 years and today is chair of Hands Off the People of Iran. After dozens of her comrades were executed in the early 80s, Mather and other members of her organisation <ins cite=\"mailto:MF\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T09:30\">&#8211; <\/ins>Fedayeen (minority) <ins cite=\"mailto:MF\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T09:30\">&#8211; <\/ins>fled to Kurdistan to continue their struggle. From exile, she <ins cite=\"mailto:MF\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T09:31\">w<\/ins><ins cite=\"mailto:Michael\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T13:33\">at<\/ins><ins cite=\"mailto:MF\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T09:31\">ched in horror as <\/ins>many more of her comrades and political friends were murdered.<\/p>\n<p>Like other exiled Iranians, she initially supported the preparations for the Iran Tribunal. She even supplied it with evidence. An impressive range of international politicians and lawyers were won to the project \u2013 <ins cite=\"mailto:MF\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T09:32\">for example, <\/ins>from Germany Norman Paech, a prominent member of Die Linke and respected professor of law.<\/p>\n<p>The first stage of the tribunal <ins cite=\"mailto:MF\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T09:32\">sat <\/ins>from June 18-22 in Amnesty International\u2019s <ins cite=\"mailto:MF\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T09:32\">London <\/ins>HQ, <ins cite=\"mailto:MF\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T09:32\">where <\/ins>60 witnesses (all of them survivors of the massacre or relatives of those murdered) <ins cite=\"mailto:MF\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T09:33\">gave 30<\/ins><ins cite=\"mailto:Michael\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T14:18\">&#8211;<\/ins><ins cite=\"mailto:MF\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T09:33\">minute accounts to the \u201c<\/ins>truth commission<ins cite=\"mailto:MF\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T09:34\">\u201d<\/ins><ins cite=\"mailto:MF\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T09:33\"> <\/ins><ins cite=\"mailto:MF\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T09:35\">detailing their experiences <\/ins>and <ins cite=\"mailto:MF\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T09:35\">those of <\/ins>their family members (<ins cite=\"mailto:Michael\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T13:33\">they <\/ins>had<ins cite=\"mailto:Michael\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T13:34\"> also<\/ins> supplied written statements beforehand). A report of 359 pages has since been published on the tribunal\u2019s website. It contains an overview of the horrific conditions <ins cite=\"mailto:MF\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T09:36\">in <\/ins>the prisons, a list of the names of the torturers and a detailed report of some executions. But the fully published witness statements <ins cite=\"mailto:MF\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T09:37\">in particular <\/ins>throw a <ins cite=\"mailto:MF\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T09:37\">harsh <\/ins>light on the brutal events. Rapes, beatings and torture were not just common, but the norm.<\/p>\n<p>None of <ins cite=\"mailto:MF\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T09:37\">this <\/ins>evidence is really new or <ins cite=\"mailto:MF\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T09:41\">previously <\/ins>unknown \u2013 but the <ins cite=\"mailto:MF\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T09:41\">sheer volume <\/ins>of <ins cite=\"mailto:MF\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T09:41\">testimony underlines the brutal truth <\/ins>that the opposition was <em>systematically<\/em> exterminated. Thousands of political prisoners were <ins cite=\"mailto:MF\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T09:44\">set <\/ins>to be released in 1988. Their <ins cite=\"mailto:MF\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T09:44\">original <\/ins>crimes? Some had been arrested for distributing leaflets, others were members of banned organisations, some had helped to organise strikes and demonstrations. Most were arrested in the first wave of oppression in the early 1980s and sentenced to six or seven years in prison.<\/p>\n<p>Their looming release came at a <ins cite=\"mailto:MF\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T09:44\">very <\/ins>inconvenient time for the government in Tehran. The <ins cite=\"mailto:MF\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T09:47\">exhausting <\/ins>and unpopular war against Iraq had come to an end, leaving the theocratic regime weakened<ins cite=\"mailto:MF\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T09:47\"> and isolated<\/ins>. <ins cite=\"mailto:MF\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T10:11\">The regime was filled with horror at the <\/ins>prospect of thousands of left and militant oppositionists <ins cite=\"mailto:MF\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T09:48\">being released to potentially <\/ins><ins cite=\"mailto:MF\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T09:49\">cohere <\/ins>and <ins cite=\"mailto:MF\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T09:49\">organise <\/ins>the growing discontent <ins cite=\"mailto:MF\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T09:49\">of <\/ins>wide <ins cite=\"mailto:MF\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T09:49\">swathes <\/ins>of the population<ins cite=\"mailto:MF\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T10:11\">.<\/ins> And so all political prisoners were dragged before makeshift courts, where an Islamic judge, a prosecutor and a representative of the intelligence services judged if they were to live or die. There were no defence lawyers, no evidence, no jury.<\/p>\n<p><ins cite=\"mailto:MF\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T10:12\">T<\/ins>he Iran Tribunal <ins cite=\"mailto:MF\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T10:12\">heard <\/ins>that the<ins cite=\"mailto:MF\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T10:16\">se kangaroo<\/ins> <ins cite=\"mailto:MF\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T10:16\">courts then demanded to know if the <\/ins>prisoners were Muslim, if they prayed to god and if they had changed their political beliefs. If <ins cite=\"mailto:MF\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T10:16\">the <\/ins>judge didn\u2019t like an answer, the defendant was sentenced to death. The <ins cite=\"mailto:MF\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T10:17\">condemned <\/ins>were piled into lorries and <ins cite=\"mailto:MF\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T10:17\">driven away to be <\/ins>hanged or shot \u2013 often in intervals of 30 minutes. Many relatives were informed only months later<ins cite=\"mailto:MF\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T10:17\">; <\/ins>others have never been told.<\/p>\n<p>This gruesome report of the truth commission will be handed to a <ins cite=\"mailto:MF\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T10:21\">\u00a0\u201c<\/ins>court<ins cite=\"mailto:MF\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T10:21\">\u201d<\/ins> in a second stage of the <ins cite=\"mailto:Michael\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T13:38\">T<\/ins><ins cite=\"mailto:MF\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T10:22\">ribunal<\/ins>. This court, made up of human rights lawyers from around the world, will meet in The Hague from October 25-27 in order evaluate the <ins cite=\"mailto:MF\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T10:22\">material <\/ins>and announce a judgement.<ins cite=\"mailto:MF\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T10:22\"><\/ins><\/p>\n<p><ins cite=\"mailto:MF\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T10:22\">\u201c<\/ins>Of course we cannot implement this judgement or the results of the commission<ins cite=\"mailto:MF\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T10:23\">\u201d<\/ins>, <ins cite=\"mailto:MF\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T10:23\">say <\/ins>the organisers. <ins cite=\"mailto:MF\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T10:23\">\u201c<\/ins>But the proceedings give tens of thousands of families a voice for the first time.<ins cite=\"mailto:MF\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T10:23\">\u201d<\/ins><\/p>\n<p><strong>Criticism<\/strong><\/p>\n<p>So far, so supportable.<ins cite=\"mailto:MF\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T10:23\"><\/ins><\/p>\n<p>However, Yassamine Mather and others <ins cite=\"mailto:MF\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T10:23\">withdrew their <\/ins><ins cite=\"mailto:MF\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T10:24\">initial <\/ins><ins cite=\"mailto:MF\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T10:23\">cooperation <\/ins>when they noticed that the <ins cite=\"mailto:MF\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T10:24\">Tribunal\u2019s <\/ins>materials <ins cite=\"mailto:MF\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T10:24\">totally failed to mention <\/ins>the <ins cite=\"mailto:MF\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T10:24\">anti-Iran <\/ins>war plans of the U<ins cite=\"mailto:MF\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T10:24\">nited <\/ins>S<ins cite=\"mailto:MF\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T10:24\">tates<\/ins> and Israel. <ins cite=\"mailto:MF\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T10:25\">\u201c<\/ins>The danger of war grows every day. I am a strong opponent of the regime in Tehran \u2013 but a war would be disastrous for the forces in Iran who have a real interest in <ins cite=\"mailto:MF\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T10:25\">democracy<\/ins>: the workers, women\u2019s groups and social movements in <ins cite=\"mailto:MF\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T10:25\">that country<\/ins>.<ins cite=\"mailto:MF\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T10:25\">\u201d<\/ins> Without clear opposition to war and sanctions, <ins cite=\"mailto:MF\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T10:25\">this Tribunal <\/ins><ins cite=\"mailto:MF\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T10:26\">effectively strengthens the hand of <\/ins>all those <ins cite=\"mailto:MF\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T10:26\">reactionary forces contemplating <\/ins>a military attack on Iran, <ins cite=\"mailto:MF\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T10:27\">Yassamine <\/ins>Mather says.<\/p>\n<p>Mather wrote to the <ins cite=\"mailto:MF\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T10:27\">Tribunal\u2019s <\/ins>committee<ins cite=\"mailto:Michael\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T13:39\"> to point out the need for a clear statement against war and sanctions. She also reminded them<\/ins> that many of those killed were <ins cite=\"mailto:MF\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T10:27\">actually <\/ins>socialists who <ins cite=\"mailto:MF\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T10:27\">were implacable not simply in their opposition<\/ins><ins cite=\"mailto:MF\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T10:28\"> to <\/ins>the Iranian regime, but also capitalism and imperialism. Surely, <ins cite=\"mailto:MF\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T10:28\">given this, <\/ins><ins cite=\"mailto:MF\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T10:29\">it was <\/ins><ins cite=\"mailto:Michael\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T13:39\">incumbent<\/ins><ins cite=\"mailto:MF\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T10:29\"> on the Tribunal to make its position on the terrible prospect of another disastrous wa<\/ins><ins cite=\"mailto:Michael\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T13:40\">r<\/ins><ins cite=\"mailto:MF\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T10:29\"> in the Middle East crystal clear<\/ins>. <ins cite=\"mailto:MF\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T10:30\">\u201c<\/ins><ins cite=\"mailto:Michael\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T13:40\"> <\/ins>I never even got a reply<ins cite=\"mailto:MF\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T10:30\">\u201d, she notes.<\/ins><\/p>\n<p>Mather and other Iranians were taken aback by this <ins cite=\"mailto:MF\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T10:30\">silence <\/ins>and took a closer look at the committee<ins cite=\"mailto:MF\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T10:31\">, its composition<\/ins> and its funding. They <ins cite=\"mailto:MF\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T10:31\">soon uncovered the fact that <\/ins>the tribunal is supported by the Iran Human Rights Documentation<ins cite=\"mailto:MF\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T10:31\"> group<\/ins>, whose founder Payam Akhavan acts as the chair and spokesperson of the <ins cite=\"mailto:MF\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T10:31\">Tribunal\u2019s <\/ins>steering committee.<\/p>\n<p><ins cite=\"mailto:MF\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T10:32\">T<\/ins>he IHRD has over the years received <ins cite=\"mailto:MF\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T10:32\">a <\/ins>large <ins cite=\"mailto:MF\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T10:32\">amount of funding <\/ins>from the US government.<a title=\"\" href=\"#_edn2\">[ii]<\/a> Akhavan is also active in Human Rights and Democracy for Iran (also known as the Abdorrahman Boroumand Foundation)<ins cite=\"mailto:MF\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T10:34\">.<\/ins> <ins cite=\"mailto:MF\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T10:34\">This <\/ins>is financed by <ins cite=\"mailto:MF\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T10:34\">a variety of <\/ins>American and European foundations, amongst them the infamous National Endowment for Democracy (NED). The NED was founded in 1983 by former US president Ronald Reagan to spread <ins cite=\"mailto:MF\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T10:35\">his version of \u201c<\/ins>democracy<ins cite=\"mailto:MF\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T10:35\">\u201d<\/ins> around the globe.<\/p>\n<p>It is <ins cite=\"mailto:MF\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T10:35\">establis<\/ins><ins cite=\"mailto:MF\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T10:36\">h<\/ins><ins cite=\"mailto:MF\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T10:35\">ed fact <\/ins>that the US has <ins cite=\"mailto:MF\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T10:36\">destab<\/ins><ins cite=\"mailto:Michael\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T14:18\">i<\/ins><ins cite=\"mailto:MF\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T10:36\">lised and sponsored <\/ins>coup <ins cite=\"mailto:Michael\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T14:19\">d\u2019\u00e9tats<\/ins> and <ins cite=\"mailto:MF\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T10:36\">proxy wars to rid itself of regimes it regards as <\/ins><ins cite=\"mailto:MF\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T10:37\">hostile to its interests<\/ins>. The CIA finances, organises and trains local <ins cite=\"mailto:MF\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T10:37\">pro-US <\/ins>opposition groups. In Chile, Guatemala and many other countries, democratically elected governments were overthrown and replaced by dictators<ins cite=\"mailto:MF\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T10:38\">,<\/ins> <ins cite=\"mailto:MF\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T10:38\">some of whom went on the oppressed their peoples <\/ins>for decades. In 1953 the CIA &#8211; with the help of the British government &#8211; toppled the democratically elected prime minister <ins cite=\"mailto:MF\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T10:38\">of Iran <\/ins>Mohammad Mossadegh.<\/p>\n<p><ins cite=\"mailto:MF\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T10:39\">While the war drums beating against Tehran make it clear that military force remains on the agenda, t<\/ins>he US\u2018 strategy has been refined and <ins cite=\"mailto:MF\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T10:40\">more layers of sophistication added<\/ins><ins cite=\"mailto:Michael\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T14:03\">. I<\/ins><ins cite=\"mailto:MF\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T10:41\">n particular, in the aftermath of the collapse of USSR and the regimes of eastern Europe, pro-Western <\/ins>regime change<ins cite=\"mailto:MF\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T10:42\"> from above is pursued under the <\/ins><ins cite=\"mailto:MF\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T10:43\">ban<\/ins><ins cite=\"mailto:Michael\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T14:02\">n<\/ins><ins cite=\"mailto:MF\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T10:43\">er of \u2018human rights\u2019 and <\/ins><ins cite=\"mailto:Michael\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T14:02\">\u2018<\/ins><ins cite=\"mailto:MF\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T10:43\">democracy<\/ins><ins cite=\"mailto:Michael\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T14:02\">\u2019<\/ins><ins cite=\"mailto:MF\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T10:43\">.<\/ins><\/p>\n<p>In the Iranian presidential elections of 2009, the West heavily supported presidential <ins cite=\"mailto:MF\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T10:46\">Green movement <\/ins>candidate Mir-Hossein Moussavi. <ins cite=\"mailto:MF\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T10:44\">The \u2018democratic\u2019 credentials of this man expose the hollowness of all the talk of <\/ins><ins cite=\"mailto:MF\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T10:45\">\u2018democracy\u2019 that comes out of Washington and London. Ironically, h<\/ins>e was <ins cite=\"mailto:MF\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T10:45\">actually <\/ins>prime minister of Iran in 1988 and <ins cite=\"mailto:MF\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T10:45\">thus <\/ins>directly responsible for the mass murders and the extermination of the opposition (even if he didn\u2019t order them personally). <ins cite=\"mailto:MF\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T10:46\">Unsurprisingly then, the <\/ins>opposition <ins cite=\"mailto:MF\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T10:46\">politically differentiated and <\/ins>split; the <ins cite=\"mailto:MF\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T10:47\">\u201cGreen <\/ins>wave<ins cite=\"mailto:MF\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T10:47\">\u201d<\/ins>, which brought more than a million people onto the streets of Iran, has largely <ins cite=\"mailto:MF\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T10:47\">ebbed <\/ins>away.<\/p>\n<p>\u201cThe NED is supposedly a private, non-government, non-profit foundation, but it receives a yearly appropriation from the US Congress\u201d, explains the former CIA agent Philip Agee in an article on the website <em>Clearing Hous<ins cite=\"mailto:MF\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T10:48\">e.<\/ins><a title=\"\" href=\"#_edn3\"><strong>[iii]<\/strong><\/a><\/em> In 2009, it was funded <ins cite=\"mailto:MF\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T10:48\">to the tune of <\/ins>$135 million by the US government.<\/p>\n<p><ins cite=\"mailto:MF\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T10:48\">\u201c<\/ins>No left activist should accept money from such sources<ins cite=\"mailto:MF\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T10:49\">\u201c<\/ins><ins cite=\"mailto:MF\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T10:48\">,<\/ins><ins cite=\"mailto:Michael\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T14:19\"> <\/ins>says Mark Fischer, chair of Hands Off the People of Iran. <ins cite=\"mailto:MF\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T10:49\">\u201cWhen they do<\/ins>, <ins cite=\"mailto:MF\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T10:49\">what started as a <\/ins><ins cite=\"mailto:MF\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T10:50\">worthy project that originated on the anti-war left &#8211; to hold the Iranian regime to account for its crimes &#8211; is <\/ins>totally <ins cite=\"mailto:MF\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T10:51\">usurped and turned into its opposite<\/ins>. The <ins cite=\"mailto:MF\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T10:51\">Tribunal <\/ins>has become part of the <ins cite=\"mailto:MF\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T10:51\">drive by Washington <\/ins>to topple the Islamic government and replace it with a US- and Israel-friendly regime.<ins cite=\"mailto:MF\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T10:51\">\u201d<\/ins><\/p>\n<p><ins cite=\"mailto:MF\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T10:52\">Hopi has been sharply criticised by some for their \u2018purism\u2019 &#8211; <\/ins><ins cite=\"mailto:MF\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T10:53\">\u2018what <\/ins>is so bad about accepting money from the US government?<ins cite=\"mailto:MF\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T10:53\">\u2019, some have asked.<\/ins> <ins cite=\"mailto:MF\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T10:53\">After all, <\/ins>it <ins cite=\"mailto:MF\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T10:53\">is <\/ins>possible to receive funds from pigs without <ins cite=\"mailto:MF\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T10:53\">having <\/ins>to grunt yourself<ins cite=\"mailto:MF\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T10:53\">. <\/ins><\/p>\n<p><ins cite=\"mailto:MF\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T10:53\">\u201c<\/ins>Of course it <ins cite=\"mailto:MF\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T10:54\">is\u201d<\/ins><ins cite=\"mailto:MF\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T10:53\">, <\/ins><ins cite=\"mailto:MF\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T10:54\">responds <\/ins>Fischer. <ins cite=\"mailto:MF\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T10:54\">\u201c<\/ins>But only if the financier places no <ins cite=\"mailto:MF\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T10:54\">political <\/ins>conditions or demands on you. But the NED is an important <ins cite=\"mailto:MF\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T10:55\">arm <\/ins>of US-sponsored foreign policy.\u201d Fischer says it is no coincidence or oversight that the website of the <ins cite=\"mailto:MF\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T10:57\">Tribunal <\/ins>does not come out in opposition to war and sanctions. Or that it does not mention <ins cite=\"mailto:MF\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T10:57\">even <\/ins>once that many of the victims of the 1988 massacre were communists and socialists.<ins cite=\"mailto:MF\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T10:57\"><\/ins><\/p>\n<p><ins cite=\"mailto:MF\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T10:57\">\u201cFinancially and politically <\/ins><ins cite=\"mailto:MF\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T10:58\">t<\/ins>he <ins cite=\"mailto:Michael\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T14:04\">Tribunal <\/ins>is <ins cite=\"mailto:MF\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T10:58\">an integral <\/ins>part of the campaign for <ins cite=\"mailto:MF\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T10:58\">\u2018<\/ins>regime change from above<ins cite=\"mailto:MF\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T10:59\">\u2018<\/ins><ins cite=\"mailto:MF\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T10:58\">\u201d, <\/ins>says Fischer. This <ins cite=\"mailto:MF\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T10:59\">is a multi-front <\/ins>campaign <ins cite=\"mailto:MF\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T11:00\">that utilises <\/ins>bombs<ins cite=\"mailto:MF\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T11:00\">,<\/ins> military threats<ins cite=\"mailto:MF\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T11:00\">, san<\/ins><ins cite=\"mailto:Michael\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T14:05\">c<\/ins><ins cite=\"mailto:MF\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T11:00\">tions,<\/ins> killer commandos <ins cite=\"mailto:MF\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T11:00\">despatched <\/ins>by the Israeli <ins cite=\"mailto:MF\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T11:00\">secret service <\/ins>Mossad<ins cite=\"mailto:MF\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T11:01\"> &#8230; and \u2018hum<\/ins><ins cite=\"mailto:MF\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T11:03\">a<\/ins><ins cite=\"mailto:MF\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T11:01\">n rights\u2019 initiatives like the Iran Tribunal<\/ins>. <ins cite=\"mailto:MF\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T11:02\">For the sake of legitimacy<\/ins><ins cite=\"mailto:MF\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T11:04\"> &#8211; esp<\/ins><ins cite=\"mailto:Michael\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T14:05\">e<\/ins><ins cite=\"mailto:MF\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T11:04\">cially when it comes to \u2018soft war\u2019 initiatives like the IT or sanctions &#8211;<\/ins><ins cite=\"mailto:MF\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T11:02\"> the <\/ins>support of <ins cite=\"mailto:MF\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T11:02\">pliant <\/ins>politicians of the <ins cite=\"mailto:MF\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T11:02\">Iranian <\/ins>opposition is <ins cite=\"mailto:MF\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T11:02\">vital in this<\/ins>. <ins cite=\"mailto:MF\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T11:02\">Indeed, some <\/ins><ins cite=\"mailto:MF\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T11:03\">of these forces <\/ins><ins cite=\"mailto:MF\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T11:02\">have <\/ins><ins cite=\"mailto:MF\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T11:03\">foolishly <\/ins><ins cite=\"mailto:MF\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T11:02\">suggested <\/ins><ins cite=\"mailto:MF\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T11:03\">that the worse the social conditions <\/ins><ins cite=\"mailto:MF\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T11:04\">become in Iran, the weaker the regime.<\/ins><\/p>\n<p><ins cite=\"mailto:MF\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T11:05\">Yassamine Mather responds: <\/ins>\u201c<ins cite=\"mailto:MF\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T11:05\">Actually, what is weakened <\/ins>first and foremost <ins cite=\"mailto:MF\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T11:05\">are <\/ins>the <ins cite=\"mailto:MF\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T11:05\">ordinary <\/ins>people in Iran. The workers\u2018 movements and women\u2019s organisations are currently <ins cite=\"mailto:MF\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T11:05\">more feeble and <\/ins><ins cite=\"mailto:Michael\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T14:19\">embattled<\/ins><ins cite=\"mailto:MF\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T11:05\"> <\/ins>than they have been for many years<ins cite=\"mailto:MF\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T11:05\">. P<\/ins>eople struggle to get by in worsening economic conditions<ins cite=\"mailto:MF\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T11:06\"> and simply have no time, space or energy for the political fight<\/ins>.\u201d<\/p>\n<p>Comrade Mather also criticises the <ins cite=\"mailto:MF\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T11:06\">composition of the <\/ins>steering committee of the <ins cite=\"mailto:MF\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T11:06\">Tribunal<\/ins>, which<ins cite=\"mailto:MF\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T11:06\"> \u201c<\/ins>reads like <ins cite=\"mailto:MF\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T11:06\">a <\/ins><ins cite=\"mailto:MF\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T11:07\">\u2018<\/ins>Who is who<ins cite=\"mailto:MF\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T11:07\">\u2019 <\/ins>of <ins cite=\"mailto:MF\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T11:07\">establishment <\/ins><ins cite=\"mailto:Michael\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T14:20\">luminaries who<\/ins><ins cite=\"mailto:MF\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T11:08\"> <\/ins>fight for <ins cite=\"mailto:MF\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T11:08\">\u2018<\/ins>human rights<ins cite=\"mailto:MF\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T11:08\">\u2019<\/ins> in a total political vacuum<ins cite=\"mailto:MF\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T11:09\">\u201d<\/ins><ins cite=\"mailto:MF\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T11:08\">: <\/ins><ins cite=\"mailto:MF\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T11:09\">eg, <\/ins>Sir Geoffrey Nice is a supporter of the Human Rights Commission of the British Conservative Party<ins cite=\"mailto:MF\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T11:09\"><\/ins>. Payam Akhavan was voted <ins cite=\"mailto:MF\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T11:10\">\u201c<\/ins>young global leader<ins cite=\"mailto:MF\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T11:10\">\u201d<\/ins> at the World Economic Forum in 2005. John Cooper QC has stood for the Labour Party in elections. All three are well-known, high-ranking lawyers who in the name of <ins cite=\"mailto:MF\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T11:10\">what they dub <\/ins><ins cite=\"mailto:MF\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T11:11\">\u201c<\/ins><ins cite=\"mailto:MF\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T11:10\">t<\/ins>he international communit<ins cite=\"mailto:MF\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T11:11\">y\u201d <\/ins>have over the years <ins cite=\"mailto:MF\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T11:16\">confronted <\/ins>many dictators and government heads in international courts (<ins cite=\"mailto:MF\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T11:16\">generally when these have <\/ins>turned on their former sponsors in the US<ins cite=\"mailto:MF\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T11:16\">, of course<\/ins>).<\/p>\n<p>The government in Tehran was able to <ins cite=\"mailto:MF\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T11:20\">easily <\/ins>dismiss the <ins cite=\"mailto:MF\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T11:21\">Tribunal <\/ins>as part of a Western plot against Iran: the radio stations \u201aVoice of America\u2018 and Radio Free Iran \u2013 both financed by <ins cite=\"mailto:MF\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T11:22\">Washington <\/ins>\u2013 broadcast the witness statements uncut and for many hours.<\/p>\n<p>Israeli socialist Mosh\u00e9 Machover believes that some of the organisers and participants have <ins cite=\"mailto:MF\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T11:22\">\u201c<\/ins>acted with evident good will, but that is not enough. It often happens that people of good intentions lend themselves out of naivety to be exploited by evil forces. This is a danger that we must always guard against. Many good people, out of genuine and justified concern for women&#8217;s rights, were duped into lending legitimacy to the invasion of Afghanistan in 2001; and similarly good people, with genuine horror of Saddam Husain&#8217;s atrocities, were duped in 2003 into lending legitimacy to the disastrous invasion of Iraq.\u201d<\/p>\n<p><ins cite=\"mailto:MF\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T11:23\">From as early as 2010, a <\/ins>number of former political prisoners have been criticising the <ins cite=\"mailto:MF\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T11:24\">mooted Tribunal <\/ins>and its links to the US government. But <ins cite=\"mailto:MF\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T11:25\">the body <\/ins>only <ins cite=\"mailto:MF\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T11:25\">became <\/ins>the subject of an international <ins cite=\"mailto:MF\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T11:25\">controversy <\/ins>when Yassamine Mather <ins cite=\"mailto:MF\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T11:27\">began <\/ins>to publish <ins cite=\"mailto:MF\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T11:28\">her <\/ins><ins cite=\"mailto:MF\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T11:29\">damning <\/ins>research in the <em>Weekly Worker<\/em> <ins cite=\"mailto:MF\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T11:28\">from <\/ins>June 2012.<ins cite=\"mailto:Tina\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T19:50\"><\/ins><\/p>\n<p><ins cite=\"mailto:Tina\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T19:50\">Many Iranians have since added to her critical voice. For example, a number of Tribunal witnesses have used their statements to condemn the links of the committee to the NED and publicly stated that they are against war and sanctions on Iran. Several organisations have withdrawn their witnesses, support for and cooperation with the Tribunal &#8211; amongst them Rahe Kargar (Komitee Ejraai) and the communist organisation Charikhaye Fadai Khalgh (one of the offshoots of the original Fedayeen). Others, like the Communist Party of Iran, have dropped their support. The Marxist-Leninist Party of Iran (Maoist) has split over the issue, as has the Iranian Left Socialist Alliance in the US and Canada. <\/ins><\/p>\n<p><ins cite=\"mailto:Tina\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T19:50\">The most ferocious criticism has come from the Tribunal\u2019s Norwegian support committee, which has since dissolved itself because it says it felt \u201cduped\u201d by the tribunal organisers. In two highly critical statements they describe how all IT witnesses who arrived in London on June 17 were taken to a briefing session where they were explicitly asked not to raise any politics during their session. They would not be asked the name of their organisation or their political views, as this was \u201cnot a political tribunal\u201d.<\/ins><\/p>\n<p><ins cite=\"mailto:Tina\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T19:50\">Worse, they then spotted Maurice Copithorne, who was about to chair one of the sessions. Between 1995 and 2002 he acted as UN human rights rapporteur for Iran. \u201cSome Iranians travelled to meet him in 1995 in order to get him to start an investigation of the 1988 massacre\u201d, according to a member of the Norwegian committee. \u201cBut they weren\u2019t even allowed to meet him. His aide told them that he would only deal with the current situation in Iran and was not interested in things from the past.\u201d <\/ins><\/p>\n<p><ins cite=\"mailto:Tina\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T19:50\">Of course, this was at a time when the US was making efforts to stage a rapprochement with the regime in Teheran and to enlist it as an ally in the fight against the Saddam Hussein regime in Iraq. It was in this geo-political context that Copithorne\u2019s annual <em>Human rights report<\/em> was seen as a \u201cpolitical whitewash\u201d of the theocracy\u2019s oppression, explains Yassamine Mather. In his 1998 report, for example, he opines that, \u201cwhile the Islamic Republic of Iran is making progress in the field of human rights, this progress is uneven and a number of sectors are, at this time, being left behind. The Government needs to broaden its agenda for change and to declare a strong commitment to achieving certain goals within specified time-frames.\u201d<\/ins><a title=\"\" href=\"#_edn4\"><ins cite=\"mailto:Tina\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T19:50\"><ins cite=\"mailto:Tina\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T19:50\">[iv]<\/ins><\/ins><\/a><ins cite=\"mailto:Tina\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T19:50\"> This brand of almost technocratic advice to encourage the Tehran regime\u2019s human rights \u201cprogress\u201d reads as surreal when the grim daily reality of poverty, repression and censorship for ordinary Iranians is borne in mind.<\/ins><\/p>\n<p><ins cite=\"mailto:Tina\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T19:50\">Copithorne\u2019s sudden interest in the 1988 massacre of political prisoners (in the new geo-political context of a US-led driven drive to war against Iran, of course) impressed few and most of the witnesses from Norway (as well as a number from Great Britain and Germany) decided at this point to withdraw from the proceedings. In protest at the farce unfolding in London, the Norwegian committee itself decided to dissolve and has since explained that they feel they had been \u201cduped\u201d by the organisers. In their statements, the presence of Copithorne, Sir Nice and John Cooper is criticised, the attempts to depoliticise the witness statements and of course Akhavan&#8217;s leading role in the whole initiative and his links to the Broumand Foundation and IHDRC are emphatically rejected.<\/ins><\/p>\n<p><ins cite=\"mailto:Tina\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T19:50\">One witness, however, wanted to challenge the tribunal and at the end of his 30-minute-session made an anti-imperialist statement. Outrageously, his whole statement has been excluded from the tribunal\u2019s report. <\/ins><\/p>\n<p><strong><ins cite=\"mailto:Tina\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T19:50\">Norman Paech<\/ins><\/strong><\/p>\n<p><ins cite=\"mailto:Tina\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T19:50\">The furore has now started to make waves amongst the non-Iranian left. When Hopi supporters confronted the leading German politician cited at the beginning of this document, Norman Paech of Die Linke, with the evidence gathered by comrade Mather, he immediately cut off his cooperation with the Tribunal. This is his statement in full:<\/ins><ins cite=\"mailto:Tina\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T19:50\"><\/ins><\/p>\n<p>&nbsp;<\/p>\n<figure id=\"attachment_2187\" aria-describedby=\"caption-attachment-2187\" style=\"width: 211px\" class=\"wp-caption alignleft\"><a href=\"http:\/\/hopoi.org\/wp-content\/uploads\/Paech.jpg\"><img loading=\"lazy\" decoding=\"async\" class=\" wp-image-2187 \" style=\"border: 2px solid black; margin-left: 5px; margin-right: 5px;\" title=\"Paech\" src=\"http:\/\/hopoi.org\/wp-content\/uploads\/Paech.jpg\" alt=\"\" width=\"211\" height=\"208\" \/><\/a><figcaption id=\"caption-attachment-2187\" class=\"wp-caption-text\">Norman Paech<\/figcaption><\/figure>\n<p>\u201cI have indeed supported the intention and the work of the committee to prepare this tribunal. I still think it is absolutely necessary that all facts about the horrific murders, the torture and the crimes of the 1980s are brought to light. But the background of the funding and the obvious links to the NED, of which I had no knowledge and which have only just been brought to my attention, make it impossible for me to continue this support. I find myself in particularly strong disagreement with the committee when it comes to my resolute opposition to sanctions and the threat of war on Iran. I do not want to part of a project which is supported by the pro-war Mujahedin.\u201d<\/p>\n<p><ins cite=\"mailto:Tina\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T19:50\">He has since come under pressure from a number of Iranians in Germany to withdraw his statement. But his political biography suggests he is astute enough to stand firm. <\/ins><\/p>\n<p><ins cite=\"mailto:Tina\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T19:50\">Paech left the then governing Social Democratic Party of Germany (SPD) in 2001, when it sent German troops to Afghanistan. He became a member of parliament for Die Linke in Germany in 2005, where he acted as the fraction\u2019s spokesperson for foreign affairs and led the (failed) attempt by the party to declare the despatch of fighter jets to Afghanistan to be illegal. In 2010 he was onboard the ship <em>Mavi Marmara<\/em>, which attempted to deliver goods and food to Gaza. Famously, it was raided by the Israeli army and nine people were killed. Afterwards, Paech and two other Die Linke members on board were heavily criticised by the German media for their involvement, which \u201calso harboured many extremists and Hamas supporters\u201d. Because of the still strong German \u2018collective guilt\u2019 complex over WWII and the holocaust, any kind of criticism is misconstrued as anti-Semitism and Paech was slammed even by right wing sections of his own party. <\/ins><\/p>\n<p><ins cite=\"mailto:Tina\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T19:50\">It is also important to point out that, to his credit, he has been very critical of attempts to charge so-called \u2018war criminals\u2019 in international courts. These courts act very much as the courts of the victors who are re-writing history for their own purpose. They are not interested in and cannot deliver \u201cjustice\u201d.<\/ins><\/p>\n<p><ins cite=\"mailto:Tina\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T19:50\">We should also have no illusions in the ability of the US, Israel or any Western government to bring democracy to Iran. Iraq and Afghanistan surely serve as horrific examples of imperialist-led \u2018regime change from above\u2019. <\/ins><\/p>\n<p><ins cite=\"mailto:Tina\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T19:50\">\u201cIn reality, the plan is to rebuild the politically unstable Middle East in a US-friendly way and preserve the regional hegemony of Israel. The biggest obstacle here is the regime in Iran\u201d, says comrade Machover. The Iran Tribunal is now a secondary, but nonetheless important, part of that reactionary project. <\/ins><\/p>\n<p><strong><ins cite=\"mailto:Tina\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T19:50\">Mujahedin<\/ins><\/strong><\/p>\n<p><ins cite=\"mailto:Tina\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T19:50\">Despite all of this, there are still a number of groups who continue to support the IT as an important element of their opposition to Teheran; for example the Mujahedin. For this organisation the overthrow of the regime in Teheran has always been <em>the<\/em> key objective and it explicitly supports sanctions and war to achieve it (in the First Gulf War, it famously sided with Saddam Hussein and militarily aided his attacks on Iran). The organisation\u2019s support for the Tribunal is actually disputed by those who run it. Hardly surprising: after all, the US government has only just announced that it is about to delist the Mujahideen-e-Khalq (MEK) as a terrorist group. Yet the involvement in the IT of people with close links to the Mujahedin seems to tell a different story.<\/ins><\/p>\n<p><ins cite=\"mailto:Tina\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T19:50\">Leila Ghalehbani (who is featured in a video on the Tribunal\u2019s front page) is the sister of a number of Mujahdin prisoners who were killed in 1988. Iraj Mesdaghi, a survivor of the massacre, describes himself as \u201ca former member\u201d of the organisation. The website of the pro-Mujahedin organisation \u2018Human rights and democracy for Iran\u2019 has just published a very sympathetic interview with Payam Akhavan in which he is sympathetically prompted to tell readers how he feels about being \u201cslandered\u201d by the <em>Weekly Worker<\/em>.<\/ins><a title=\"\" href=\"#_edn5\"><ins cite=\"mailto:Tina\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T19:50\"><ins cite=\"mailto:Tina\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T19:50\">[v]<\/ins><\/ins><\/a><ins cite=\"mailto:Tina\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T19:50\"><\/ins><\/p>\n<p><ins cite=\"mailto:Tina\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T19:50\">\u201cFor some, the end justifies the means\u201d, concludes Yassamine Mather. \u201cThey think that sanctions, the Tribunal, even the threat of war will help to topple the regime in Iran and their day will have come. But they seem to wilfully ignore the fact that the US and Israel have no interest in democracy of any sort for Iran. So, they are playing a dangerous game. I am sure that many of those who were killed in 1988 would turn in their grave if they could now see what has happened to their comrades.\u201c<\/ins><\/p>\n<p><ins cite=\"mailto:Tina\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T19:50\">Hopefully, many other politicians and left activists and organisations follow Norman Paech\u2019s lead and disengage from the Tribunal. What we need is a real, independent tribunal that can investigate the crimes \u2013 and at the same time speak out against war and sanctions on Iran. <\/ins><\/p>\n<p><strong><ins cite=\"mailto:Tina\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T19:50\">Notes<\/ins><\/strong><\/p>\n<div>\n<hr align=\"left\" size=\"1\" width=\"33%\" \/>\n<div>\n<p><a title=\"\" href=\"#_ednref1\">[i]<\/a> http:\/\/www.hintergrund.de\/201209222250\/politik\/welt\/viele-der-ermordeten-wuerden-sich-im-grab-umdrehen.html?utm_source=feedburner&amp;utm_medium=twitter&amp;utm_campaign=Feed%3A+hintergrund%2FZboE+%28hintergrund.de%29<\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div>\n<p><a title=\"\" href=\"#_ednref2\">[ii]<\/a> www.iranhrdc.org\/english\/news\/in-the-news\/3085-silencing-the-watchdog.html#.T9RP7NPgyBs.<\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div>\n<p><a title=\"\" href=\"#_ednref3\">[iii]<\/a> http:\/\/en.wikipedia.org\/wiki\/National_Endowment_for_Democracy#Funding_of_foreign_political_candidates<\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div>\n<p><a title=\"\" href=\"#_ednref4\"><ins cite=\"mailto:Tina\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T19:50\"><ins cite=\"mailto:Tina\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T19:50\">[iv]<\/ins><\/ins><\/a><ins cite=\"mailto:Tina\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T19:50\"> http:\/\/www.iranrights.org\/english\/document-74.php<\/ins><\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div>\n<p><a title=\"\" href=\"#_ednref5\"><ins cite=\"mailto:Tina\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T19:50\"><ins cite=\"mailto:Tina\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T19:50\">[v]<\/ins><\/ins><\/a><ins cite=\"mailto:Tina\" datetime=\"2012-09-28T19:50\"> http:\/\/www.hrd4iran.se\/<\/ins><\/p>\n<p>&nbsp;<\/p>\n<\/div>\n<\/div>\n","protected":false},"excerpt":{"rendered":"<p>Norman Paech, a prominent member of the German left Party Die Linke, has joined others in withdrawing his support for the Iran Tribunal after approaches from supporters of Hands Off the People of Iran, reports Tina Becker This is an edited version of an article recently published on the website of the German magazine Hintergrund.[i] &hellip; <\/p>\n<p class=\"link-more\"><a href=\"https:\/\/hopoi.org\/?p=2185\" class=\"more-link\">Continue reading<span class=\"screen-reader-text\"> &#8220;Iran Tribunal: \u2018Impossible to continue support\u2019&#8221;<\/span><\/a><\/p>\n","protected":false},"author":2,"featured_media":0,"comment_status":"open","ping_status":"open","sticky":false,"template":"","format":"standard","meta":{"footnotes":""},"categories":[2],"tags":[145,268,278,442],"class_list":["post-2185","post","type-post","status-publish","format-standard","hentry","category-articles","tag-democracy","tag-iran","tag-iran-tribunal","tag-ned","entry"],"_links":{"self":[{"href":"https:\/\/hopoi.org\/index.php?rest_route=\/wp\/v2\/posts\/2185","targetHints":{"allow":["GET"]}}],"collection":[{"href":"https:\/\/hopoi.org\/index.php?rest_route=\/wp\/v2\/posts"}],"about":[{"href":"https:\/\/hopoi.org\/index.php?rest_route=\/wp\/v2\/types\/post"}],"author":[{"embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/hopoi.org\/index.php?rest_route=\/wp\/v2\/users\/2"}],"replies":[{"embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/hopoi.org\/index.php?rest_route=%2Fwp%2Fv2%2Fcomments&post=2185"}],"version-history":[{"count":0,"href":"https:\/\/hopoi.org\/index.php?rest_route=\/wp\/v2\/posts\/2185\/revisions"}],"wp:attachment":[{"href":"https:\/\/hopoi.org\/index.php?rest_route=%2Fwp%2Fv2%2Fmedia&parent=2185"}],"wp:term":[{"taxonomy":"category","embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/hopoi.org\/index.php?rest_route=%2Fwp%2Fv2%2Fcategories&post=2185"},{"taxonomy":"post_tag","embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/hopoi.org\/index.php?rest_route=%2Fwp%2Fv2%2Ftags&post=2185"}],"curies":[{"name":"wp","href":"https:\/\/api.w.org\/{rel}","templated":true}]}}